Reverb vs Guitar Center: Which Selling Route Makes Sense?
On this page
If you have a store quote in hand and wonder whether listing on Reverb is worth the extra work, it comes down to one calculation: what you’d keep from an online sale versus what the store will pay you today. Here’s how to compare the two fairly.
The Basic Difference
| Reverb | Guitar Center | |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | The price a buyer agrees to, minus your costs | The store’s quote |
| Certainty | It may not sell at your asking price, or at all | A firm offer you can accept on the spot |
| Your work | Photos, listing, answering questions, packing, shipping | Bringing the guitar in |
| Timing | Depends on demand and price, with no set timeline | Can be done during your visit if you accept |
A store has to resell your guitar at a profit, so its offer will be lower than the price it expects to sell for. No single percentage applies to every guitar, so get a real quote instead of guessing.
Asking Prices vs Completed Sales
Before you count on $800 as your Reverb price, check whether that’s an asking price or a sale price. Active listings show what sellers want. Completed transactions are better evidence, although sold listings can hide accepted offers and still display the original asking price. Use transaction prices or price-guide ranges where available, and plan around a realistic sale price rather than the highest active listing.
Worked Example: $800 Listing vs $480 Quote
The numbers below are made up for illustration. Swap the assumed fees and shipping for your own figures from the platform’s and carrier’s current pages.
Assumptions:
- Store quote: $480
- Reverb listing price: $800
- Selling and payment fees: 10% of the sale price combined
- Shipping: $60, paid by you
- Packing materials: $15
| Scenario | Sale price | Assumed fees | Shipping + packing | Assumed net | Gap vs $480 quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sells at full asking price | $800 | $80 | $75 | $645 | +$165 |
| Sells after an offer | $720 | $72 | $75 | $573 | +$93 |
| Store quote | $480 | $0 | $0 | $480 | $0 |
With these assumptions, Reverb puts about $93 to $165 more in your pocket. The question is whether that gap is worth the time spent taking photos, writing the listing, messaging buyers, packing, and dropping off a box. Selling online also comes with some risk, such as shipping damage or a return. To see the gap for your guitar, enter your listing price, assumed fees, shipping, and store quote into the trade-in calculator.
The $75 shipping and packing line is only a placeholder. Packing and shipping a guitar properly means measuring the box against carrier limits and choosing coverage, and both can change that figure. On the store side, the Guitar Center trade-in offer and payment rules explain how quotes are set at inspection, so both columns rest on real numbers.
When the Store Quote Makes Sense
- The gap is small once you subtract your costs.
- You need the money or the space now.
- You’re trading toward new gear. If the store offers a different amount for credit than for cash, ask about both.
- You don’t want to pack and ship an instrument.
When Reverb Makes Sense
- The gap is large enough to be worth the work.
- The guitar is niche or collectible, and buyers who know gear may value it more than a store would.
- You’re comfortable packing and shipping it safely.
- You can wait without a deadline.
Other Places to Sell
Reverb and Guitar Center aren’t your only options. Local private sales, specialist dealers, and eBay each come with their own trade-offs. See where to sell a guitar for a full comparison.
